Why Change Feels So Hard and How DBT Helps You Move Forward

Jean-Gabrielle Short • November 1, 2025

Understanding Why Change Feels So Hard

Most of us want to change something about our lives — to feel calmer, relate differently, stop repeating old patterns, or simply get unstuck. Yet, even when the desire for change is strong, something inside resists. Clients often tell me, “I know what I should do, but I can’t seem to make myself do it.”

That gap between intention and action is where DBT does its best work. DBT recognises that change is not just a decision; it’s a process that unfolds against the background of our biology, emotions, environment, and history. When we try to change, we’re not fighting laziness — we’re negotiating with our nervous system, habits, and fears.

DBT is built on the dialectic of acceptance and change. Both are needed. Acceptance helps us see things as they are without judgement. Change gives us the tools to move forward effectively. Without acceptance, we stay stuck in resistance; without change, acceptance becomes resignation.

The Science of Resistance

From a psychological perspective, change threatens predictability. Our brains are wired to prefer the familiar, even when it’s painful. The amygdala; the brain’s alarm system interprets uncertainty as danger, triggering avoidance or over-control responses. For individuals with heightened emotional sensitivity, that threat response can feel overwhelming.

In DBT, we frame this as part of the problem to be solved, not a personal flaw. Resistance becomes data. It tells us that part of the mind is trying to protect us from discomfort, rejection, or loss. Change, in this light, means learning to approach discomfort rather than eliminate it.

“I Want to, But I Freeze”

During one group session, Emma (not her real nam) shared that she felt “paralysed” every time she tried to set boundaries with her partner. She understood the skill intellectually but said, “When I open my mouth, I freeze. My heart races, my brain blanks out, and I end up giving in.”

Instead of focusing on the boundary itself, we paused to notice what was happening in her body- the tightening chest, the urge to appease. Together, we practised mindfulness of current emotion and the TIPP skill (Temperature, Intense exercise, Paced breathing, Progressive relaxation). Within a few weeks, Emma learned that regulating her physiological arousal first made space for skillful action.

This is what DBT means by building mastery through small steps. We do not demand instant transformation; we teach the body and mind to tolerate discomfort in manageable doses.

The Role of Willingness

One of the central concepts in DBT’s Reality Acceptance module is willingness- the capacity to open oneself to what is, and to do what works in the moment, even when it’s uncomfortable. Its opposite, wilfulness, sounds like resistance: “I don’t want to,” “I shouldn’t have to,” or “It won’t work anyway.”

Wilfulness is a natural human reaction to pain. When life feels unfair, wilfulness tries to reclaim control. Yet, paradoxically, it keeps us stuck. Willingness, by contrast, invites movement. It doesn’t mean liking reality, agreeing with it, or giving up; it means choosing to participate fully in the present moment so that change becomes possible.

In therapy, I sometimes invite clients to practise “turning the mind” consciously shifting from wilfulness to willingness. We pause, breathe, and ask:

What would willingness look like right now?

This small question often opens the door to action.

Skill Spotlight: Willingness vs Wilfulness

Here’s how to practise this skill at home:

Notice resistance.

Pay attention to moments when you feel yourself saying “no” to reality. It might appear as tension in your shoulders, self-critical thoughts, or avoidance behaviours.

Pause and breathe.

Take a slow, mindful breath. Unclench your hands or soften your posture — physical willingness supports emotional openness.

Name the wilfulness.

Silently acknowledge, “I’m feeling wilful right now.” Naming it reduces its power.

Turn the mind.

Intentionally choose willingness: “I am open to doing what works.”

Act effectively.

Take one small, value-aligned step, even if it’s uncomfortable.

Over time, this practice helps clients move from avoidance to participation, from rigidity to flexibility.

“I’m Scared It Won’t Work”

Another client, Renee, struggled with hopelessness. After years of therapy, she feared nothing would change. Early in DBT, she often said, “What’s the point? I’ve tried everything.”

In one session, we used the “Pros and Cons” skill — a DBT strategy for increasing motivation by writing out the short- and long-term consequences of acting on or resisting a behaviour. Together, we explored the pros and cons of avoiding therapy homework versus practising one new skill per week.

Initially, the pros of avoidance were compelling: less anxiety, less effort. But the long-term cons — feeling stagnant, disconnected, and self-critical — resonated deeply. By visualising both paths, Renee recognised that staying still was also a form of suffering. Her willingness to experiment with small behavioural changes grew from that insight.

Within months, she began journalling daily and practising mindfulness for three minutes each morning. Her mood improved, not because the work was easy, but because she was no longer at war with herself.

Balancing Acceptance and Change

At the heart of DBT is dialectical thinking- the idea that two seemingly opposite truths can both be valid. You can accept yourself fully and still want to change. You can acknowledge pain and choose to act effectively. This balance transforms black-and-white thinking into a more flexible, compassionate stance toward life.

Clients often describe this as a relief. Instead of asking, “What’s wrong with me?” they begin asking, “What skill could help me here?” That shift alone is profound.

Why Small Steps Matter

Change rarely arrives in grand gestures. It shows up in the moment you pause instead of reacting, the time you validate yourself instead of criticising, or when you attend group despite wanting to cancel. Each act of willingness strengthens neural pathways associated with self-regulation and hope.

In DBT, we celebrate these micro-changes because they reflect real, lived transformation. The goal isn’t perfection, it’s effectiveness: doing what works in the service of a life worth living.

Moving Forward

If you find yourself stuck between wanting change and fearing it, you’re not alone. Every client who has ever walked into a DBT session has felt that same ambivalence. The work begins with acknowledging both sides: the part of you that hopes and the part that hesitates.

Start small. Practise willingness once a day. Try a skill even when you don’t feel ready. Change begins in those moments of gentle persistence.

You don’t have to believe it will work; you only have to be willing to try ~ that is the heart of DBT.

< Older Post

Newer Post >